| Walking Concert - "Run to be Born" | | (nenhum voto) |
| The Delgados - "Universal Audio" | | (nenhum voto) |
| Jens Lekman - "When I sad I wanted to be your Dog" | | 8.33% (2 votos) |
| The Legends - "Up Against the Legends" | | 4.17% (1 voto) |
| Interpol - "Antics" | | 58.33% (14 votos) |
| Pinback - "Summer is Abaddon" | | (nenhum voto) |
| The Zutons - "Who Killed ... The Zutons" | | 8.33% (2 votos) |
| The Music - "Welcome to the North" | | 16.67% (4 votos) |
| Elliott Smith - "From a Basement to the Hill" | | 4.17% (1 voto) |
| Le Tigre - "This Island" | | (nenhum voto) |
